stethoscope and healthcare business graphic composite

The Case of an Open Mind

Woman embracing the wind on beach

A cardinal prerequisite for a successful career in science is the willingness to be willing to change one’s mind as to the answer to a hypothesis based on the scientific results of the experiment. For investigations and observations of the pandemic and the COVID-19 virus, continued scientific analysis has resulted in different medical recommendations and treatments. For more than 20 months we have heard a long parade of new data and resultant conclusions. This parade is not over, and we must keep an open mind going forward. But, for now, consider these six facts:

  1. The risk of contracting COVID-19 for a fully vaccinated person is between 1 in 5,000 and 1 in 10,000 per day depending on where you live and the surrounding prevalence of the disease in your area. For example, the risk is higher in Florida than in Maine as there are more cases occurring daily now in Florida.
  2. If you are unvaccinated, your risk of contracting COVID-19 is 10 times that of the vaccinated population. This fact is magnified in a state like Florida where the incidence of new COVID-19 cases is high. For those unfortunate enough to contract COVID-19, the unvaccinated person is approximately 17 times more likely to be hospitalized than a fully vaccinated person.
  3. In a highly vaccinated community, the daily risk of a fully vaccinated person entering the hospital of dying of COVID-19 approaches 1 in a million. This risk is less than the risk of a day of commuting travel or a day boating in Florida waters. Full vaccination provides excellent protection from serious COVID-19.
  4. The newest float in the COVID-19 parade is the question of waning immunity and the need and timing of booster vaccines. The current position of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the federal administration regarding booster vaccination will become clearer by the end of September. Despite the estimates of gradual waning of immunity, the data still supports a high level of protection at 6-8 months for those fully vaccinated. Pfizer, Moderna, and Johnson & Johnson booster shots will be available when authorized. At present there is enough early data to support booster shots for the immunosuppressed, frontline healthcare workers, and possibly those over the age of 65 with high-risk medical conditions. Booster shots are being administered outside approved guidelines for those who feel that they do not want to wait for the official approval. Given the anxiety over the potential seriousness of severe Covid-19, this reaction is understandable. The debate over this issue will continue until the breakthrough infection data and the antibody response and protection data is analyzed.
  5. The effort to convince anti-vaxxers continues. Trying to convince the unvaccinated to get shots seems about as promising as teaching ospreys to eat iguanas on Boca Grande. Yet, evidence supporting mass vaccination continues to mount. The benefits of expanding full vaccination to all adults is indisputable on strictly medical terms.
  6. Vaccination, indoor mask wearing and social distancing still provide the best plan for ending the pandemic, maximizing safety for our children and the elderly, continuing the economic recovery for all, and protecting the healthcare system.

Please listen to the science, as well as the politics and cultural rhetoric. Maintain an open mind to new medical data as it is presented. We all want this pandemic behind us as soon as possible.

About the Author

Dr. Ervin joined the Clinic in November 2014, practicing internal medicine. His educational background includes medical school at the University of Rochester and a medical internship at Strong Memorial Hospital in Rochester, New York and Beth Israel Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts. He received hematology/oncology training at Dana Farber Cancer Institute and is board certified in […]

More Recent Healthcare News

  • May is National Stroke Awareness month, so let’s talk about what it is and how to avoid it. How big a deal is it? Stroke is the leading cause of long-term disability and the fifth leading cause of death in the United States. Women are at a slightly higher risk of stroke at 1 out […]

  • As part of our year-long celebration of the Boca Grande Health Clinic’s 75th anniversary, the Clinic is pleased present a short series of web videos that capture some of the “secrets” to having a long, productive life – told by some of the Island’s elders. The third episode of the series features Robert (Bob) McKinney, […]

  • As part of our year-long celebration of the Boca Grande Health Clinic’s 75th anniversary, the Clinic is pleased to launch a short series of web videos that capture some of the “secrets” to having a long, productive life – told by some of the Island’s elders. In the second episode of the series, we hear […]

  • COVID-19 vial

    On March 28, 2022, the U.S Food and Drug Administration (FDA) authorized the administration of a second COVID-19 booster shot for persons over the age of 50. Additionally, persons over the age of 18 with compromised immune systems are also eligible for a second booster shot. Both Pfizer and Moderna mRNA shots have been granted […]